Pantone, Hex, RGB, and CIELab: Color Matching in Garment Printing

Pantone, Hex, RGB, and CIELab: Color Matching in Garment Printing

When working with customers on apparel printing projects, color communication is key. Clients might reference Pantone codes, Hex values, or RGB colors from a screen, expecting the print to match. Understanding the differences between these color systems – and the limitations of each in screen printing (SP), direct-to-film (DTF), or direct-to-garment (DTG) printing – will help set the right expectations. Below is a brief guide for Customer Service, Sales, and Production teams, with pointers to more detailed resources.

Pantone (PMS) Colors and Spot Inks in Screen Printing

Pantone Matching System (PMS) colors are standardized, pre-mixed inks defined by the Pantone company. Each Pantone color has a unique code and precise ink formula, ensuring consistent results across different printers and materials[1]. In screen printing, Pantone spot colors are the gold standard for accuracy – providing a PMS number tells the printer exactly what ink to use. Screen printers often love Pantone because it removes guesswork and variation: the color doesn’t change from printer to printer when the specified PMS ink is used[2]
.

Pantone strengths: If a customer’s brand blue is PMS 285, you can print that exact hue by using the Pantone ink or mixing it according to formula. This is ideal for logos or uniforms where color accuracy is critical[1]. Limitations: Pantone inks can be costly and are usually reserved for high-stakes or larger print runs[3]. Also, if you’re using digital methods (DTF/DTG) which rely on CMYK inks, you can’t literally load a Pantone ink – you can only simulate it by mixing CMYK. As a result, not all Pantone colors can be perfectly reproduced in DTF/DTG printing due to the limited color gamut of CMYK printers[4]. (For example, metallic or fluorescent Pantones fall outside standard CMYK and cannot be achieved in DTG prints[5]
.)

👉 More info: Pantone’s official guides and print industry articles (like Techkon’s guide) discuss how Pantone spot colors are defined in Lab values and converted for CMYK printing[6]
, and why they’re crucial for brand consistency.

Hex Codes and RGB Colors vs. Printing (DTF/DTG)

Hex codes (e.g. #FF6600) and RGB values (e.g. 255,102,0) are used for on-screen colors – websites, digital graphics, and anything viewed on a monitor[7][8]. These formats are not used in physical printing. A color you see on a backlit screen often looks more vibrant than it will in print, because screens emit light (RGB is additive color), while prints rely on reflected light (CMYK inks)[9][10]. In other words, the bright neon blue a customer loves on their laptop might print as a duller blue-purple on a t-shirt. This happens because CMYK’s gamut (range of reproducible colors) is narrower than RGB’s – many super-bright or “glowing” colors on screen simply fall outside what ink can replicate, and they will shift or dull when converted to print[11]
.

If a client provides only a hex code or an RGB color from their website, you’ll need to convert or match it to print colors. The best practice is to find an equivalent in CMYK or a close Pantone swatch. For instance, a pure digital cyan #00FFFF might correspond to a Pantone or a CMYK mix that looks a bit more subdued in print. Always let customers know that RGB/Hex colors are for screens and will be converted for printing – otherwise the result may not look “exactly the same” as their online image[12]. This simple explanation can prevent surprises: “Colors from a computer screen might not convert to the exact same color when printed,” so we adjust files to the proper print color mode[12]. (Tip: The Omega Print blog recommends converting Hex/RGB designs to CMYK or Pantone before printing to avoid unexpected color shifts[13]
.)

CIELab Color Space and Accurate Color Matching

CIE L*a*b* (Lab) is a universal color space often used behind the scenes for color matching. Unlike RGB or CMYK, Lab is device-independent – it defines color based on human vision, not on the output device[14][15]. Lab can describe all colors visible to the human eye (a larger gamut than both RGB and CMYK)[16]
. In practice, we use Lab values as a neutral reference to translate colors between devices and to measure color accuracy.

For example, Pantone provides official Lab values for each PMS color. Our RIP software and color profiling tools use those Lab references to compute the best CMYK mix to simulate that Pantone on our DTG/DTF printer[6]. Lab is also used in quality control: we can print a small test patch, measure its Lab value with a spectrophotometer, and compare it to the target color’s Lab value. The Delta E (difference) tells us how far off the color is – helping decide if the match is acceptable or needs adjusting[17]
. While customers typically won’t cite Lab values, it’s good for our team to know that Lab underpins color consistency and communication across different media.

👉 More info: Techkon’s LAB Color Space guide explains why Lab is essential in printing for consistent color management[18][19]
. It also covers how Lab and Delta E are used to maintain brand colors across various printers and materials.

Common Challenges and Best Practices for Customer Communication

When a client wants a specific color on their garments, keep these points in mind:

  • Screen vs. Print Reality: A color that looks one way on a glowing screen will often look different on cotton or polyester. Always clarify that RGB/Hex colors are for digital use, and printed output (whether via screen print or DTG) may not look as bright or exact[12]
    . Manage expectations by showing a physical color swatch or a printed sample when possible.
  • Pantone for Precision: If the job permits (larger quantity or budget for setup), suggest screen printing with Pantone inks for critical colors. This yields the most predictable results. For example, if a corporate client must have their exact brand color, using the PMS ink in screen printing ensures “the exact color you’re expecting”[2]. In digital printing, we will do our best to simulate the Pantone with CMYK inks, but explain that a perfect Pantone match is usually not achievable with DTF/DTG technology[4]
    . Most customers appreciate the honesty and the effort to get as close as possible.
  • DTF/DTG Color Limitations: Direct-to-garment and DTF prints are fantastic for full-color designs and gradients, but they have some inherent limitations. They cannot reproduce certain special colors (no true metallic gold/silver, neon fluorescents, etc.)[5]
    . Extremely vivid colors might print a bit less intense. Make it a practice to inform customers that “there may be slight color variation” in digital prints. If they have strict brand guidelines, a small test print or a proof can save headaches.
  • Converting Artwork: Internally, ensure that artwork files are prepared in the correct color mode for printing. An RGB file should be converted to CMYK before final print, or imported into the RIP which will handle the conversion – but conversion can alter some hues[9][20]
    . If a customer-designed their art in RGB (common in Canva or Photoshop defaults), it’s worth previewing the CMYK version to catch any shifts. This proactive step can be explained to the client as part of our quality check.
  • Using Lab for QA: For high-profile jobs, our production team can use Lab measurements to validate color accuracy. While you wouldn’t discuss Lab values with a typical client, you can reassure them that we have professional color management in place – essentially, we’re measuring the print output against the desired color and ensuring it’s within an acceptable tolerance (industry standard Delta E)[17]
    . This kind of assurance often builds confidence, especially with clients who have dealt with color issues before.
  • Refer to Trusted Resources: If a customer or team member wants to learn more, don’t hesitate to share reputable articles. For instance, the Transfer Express blog explains the basic difference between RGB (screen colors) and Pantone/CMYK (print colors) in simple terms[2][12]. There are also guides on color matching in digital printing – e.g., DTF printing guides that discuss RGB vs CMYK design considerations[10][20]
    and print industry blogs about using Delta E and Lab for color accuracy. Providing an external reference can help back up our explanations without overwhelming the customer with technical detail.

By understanding these color systems and their challenges, our team can better guide customers in choosing the right approach. Whether it’s picking a close Pantone match for a Hex code they found online, or explaining why a neon color might print a bit muted, this knowledge ensures we deliver the best possible result and keep the client in the loop. In short: use Pantone for spot-on matches when you can, convert RGB artwork to CMYK for printing, and use Lab-based tools internally to hit those tough colors. And always communicate openly about the process – it turns a confusing topic into a collaborative effort towards a great-looking garment.


Understanding Color Spaces for DTF Printing: RGB, CMYK, and Pantone Explained

What's the Difference Between RGB, CMYK and PMS Colors? - Transfer Express Blog

  What are the direct to garment (dtg) printing drawbacks?

LAB Color Space: A Key to Accurate Printing

The Difference Between HEX, RGB, CMYK, and Pantone (and Why It Matters)

Color Alignment FAQ - Pantone


    • Related Articles

    • CIMPRESS - CSR

      CIMPRESS - CSR Sales Order/Art 1.0 S.O.P. Version 1.0 10/21/2024 OBJECTIVE The following guide is used to understand how Cimpress Sales Orders are to be processed, how art is obtained and setup, and how to troubleshoot orders. OVERVIEW We created a ...
    • SOURCED GOODS UNPACKING WAREHOUSE S.O.P

      OVERVIEW Sourced Goods pieces are purchased by the inventory team daily using the PO Builder screens in Impress. Packages for Sourced Goods orders arrive with a special Vantage PO number, for example “P123456-S12345”. Where the P number represents ...
    • Sourced Goods unpacking process in VAT

      OVERVIEW Sourced Goods pieces are purchased by the inventory team daily using the PO Builder screens in Impress. Packages for Sourced Goods orders arrive with a special Vantage PO number, for example “P123456-S12345”. Where the P number represents ...
    • How to set up and maintain Customer cross reference and UPCs in Impress.

      ? Overview Customer SKU cross-references are essential for: - EDI 850/846/810 compliance - PromoStandards Inventory/Item/Invoice APIs - Pre-decorated Pick/Pack programs - Hangtag and barcode generation - Retail integration (Amazon, Walmart, team ...
    • GNC - Order Automation

      Header and Detail Flat Txt Files and PDF get FTP'd to us. Header Flat File (contains "hd") Detail Flat File (contains "dt") PDF NOTE: The file names begin with the last 3 digits of the wave name... IE if Dody asks about "wave 15662", the files start ...